Movies like Slender Man

6 Souls

2010

forest, fear, supernatural · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

The Blair Witch Project

1999

forest, fear, urban legend · Horror, Mystery

The Bye Bye Man

2017

urban legend, supernatural · Horror, Thriller

undertone

2026

fear, supernatural · Horror, Mystery

The Cellar

2022

mysterious disappearance, supernatural · Horror, Mystery

Flight 7500

2014

supernatural · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

The Soul Eater

2024

mysterious disappearance · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

Blair Witch

2016

forest, supernatural · Horror, Thriller

Case 39

2009

supernatural · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

Demonic

2015

missing person, supernatural · Horror, Thriller

The Car

1977

small town, supernatural · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

The Midnight Man

2016

fear, urban legend · Horror

The Apparition

2012

fear, supernatural · Horror, Thriller

The Canal

2014

supernatural · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

The Messengers

2007

Horror, Mystery, Thriller · Screen Gems

Devil

2010

supernatural · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

Eloise

2016

Close on feel, same era · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

The Forest

2016

supernatural · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

Mary

2019

fear · Horror, Mystery

Sleep

2023

Close on feel, same era · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

Jessabelle

2014

supernatural · Horror, Thriller

Willow Creek

2013

forest · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

Opus

2025

mysterious disappearance · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

Ghost House

2017

Close on feel, same era · Horror, Mystery, Thriller