Shows like Midnight Mass

The Haunting of Bly Manor

2020

Also Mike Flanagan · horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery · with Rahul Kohli and Henry Thomas · Intrepid Pictures · on Netflix

The Midnight Club

2022

Also Mike Flanagan · horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery · with Annarah Cymone and Samantha Sloyan · Intrepid Pictures · on Netflix

Evil

2019

priest, horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Chapelwaite

2021

vampire · Horror, Drama, Mystery

American Gods

2017

ex-con, mysterious man · Drama, Mystery

Salem's Lot

2004

priest, vampire, horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Requiem

2018

horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery

The Summer Hikaru Died

2025

horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery

The Exorcist

2016

priest, horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina

2018

horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery · on Netflix

Dark

2017

priest · Drama, Mystery · on Netflix

Equinox

2020

island · Drama · on Netflix

FROM

2022

horror, sheriff · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Monster

2004

intense, complex · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Greenleaf

2016

church, religion · Drama

The Outsider

2020

alcoholism, horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Grotesquerie

2024

horror, intense · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Archive 81

2022

horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery · on Netflix

The OA

2016

Close on feel, same era · Drama, Mystery · on Netflix

The Third Day

2020

island · Drama, Mystery

Another

2012

horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Paranormal

2020

Close on feel, same era · Horror, Drama, Mystery · on Netflix

Don't Come Home

2024

horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery · on Netflix

Servant

2019

horror · Horror, Drama, Mystery