Shows like Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin

I Know What You Did Last Summer

2021

slasher · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Absentia

2017

slasher · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Burning Body

2023

thriller · Drama, Mystery

Swamp Thing

2019

Horror, Drama, Mystery · Warner Bros. Television

The Institute

2025

thriller · Horror, Mystery

The Monster of Florence

2025

thriller · Drama, Mystery

Danganronpa: The Animation

2013

Close on feel, same era · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Chucky

2021

lgbt, slasher · Horror, Mystery

Ajin

2016

thriller · Horror, Mystery

Fool Me Once

2024

thriller · Drama, Mystery

American Horror Story

2011

lgbt, slasher · Horror, Drama, Mystery

You

2018

thriller · Drama, Mystery · Warner Bros. Television

Teacup

2024

Close on feel, same era · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Night Has Come

2023

Close on feel, same era · Horror, Drama, Mystery

The Better Sister

2025

thriller · Drama, Mystery

My Name

2021

thriller · Drama, Mystery

Behind Closed Doors

2011

thriller · Drama, Mystery

Riverdale

2017

Also Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa · lgbt · Horror, Drama, Mystery · Warner Bros. Television

Harlan Coben's Shelter

2023

thriller, lgbt · Drama, Mystery

Red Rose

2022

Close on feel, same era · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Don't Come Home

2024

thriller · Horror, Drama, Mystery

The Mess You Leave Behind

2020

thriller · Drama, Mystery

As You Stood By

2025

thriller · Drama, Mystery

Disclaimer

2024

thriller · Drama, Mystery