Movies like In the Mouth of Madness

Dark City

1998

lovecraftian, paranoia, suspenseful · Mystery · New Line Cinema

The Thing

1982

Also John Carpenter · paranoia, lovecraftian · Horror, Mystery

Pi

1998

paranoia, insanity · Drama, Mystery, Thriller

Lost Highway

1997

paranoia, insanity · Drama, Mystery, Thriller

Prince of Darkness

1987

Also John Carpenter · church, lovecraftian · Horror

Videodrome

1983

insanity, paranoia, depressed · Horror, Mystery

The Witch

2016

new england, new hampshire · Drama, Horror, Mystery

Horsemen

2009

church, suspenseful · Horror, Drama, Mystery

The Sentinel

1977

church, frightened, crucifix · Horror, Mystery, Fantasy

The Mothman Prophecies

2002

paranoia, small town · Horror, Drama, Mystery

Viking Wolf

2022

frightened, small town, suspenseful · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

The Lighthouse

2019

lovecraftian, new england · Drama, Thriller, Fantasy

Gozu

2003

disappearance · Drama, Horror, Mystery

Color Out of Space

2020

new england, lovecraftian · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

Angel Heart

1987

church · Horror, Mystery

Regression

2015

church, paranoia · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

Black Swan

2010

insanity, paranoia · Horror, Drama, Thriller

Twelve Monkeys

1995

suspenseful, insanity, paranoia · Mystery, Thriller

The Devil All the Time

2020

church, small town, gothic · Drama, Thriller

Sleepy Hollow

1999

gothic, small town · Horror, Mystery, Thriller

Weapons

2025

small town · Horror, Mystery · New Line Cinema

Event Horizon

1997

lovecraftian, insanity · Horror, Mystery · with Sam Neill

Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

1992

small town · Horror, Drama, Mystery

The Order

2003

Close on feel, same era · Drama, Mystery, Thriller