Movies like They/Them

Psycho Killer

2026

slasher, murder, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Bloodline

2019

slasher, murder, serial killer · Horror · Blumhouse Productions

Leviticus

2026

conversion therapy, lgbt, gay theme · Horror

Black Christmas

2019

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery · Blumhouse Productions

Black Phone 2

2025

slasher, murder, camp · Horror · Blumhouse Productions

Martyrs

2015

murder · Horror, Mystery · Blumhouse Productions

Torso

1973

slasher, murder, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

My Soul to Take

2010

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Unfriended

2014

Horror, Mystery · Blumhouse Productions

In Dreams

1999

murder, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Lee Cronin's The Mummy

2026

Horror, Mystery · Blumhouse Productions

Paranormal Activity 2

2010

Horror, Mystery · Blumhouse Productions

Desperation

2006

serial killer · Horror, Mystery

The Taking of Deborah Logan

2014

serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Trauma

1993

murder, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Dark Glasses

2022

murder, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Cherry Falls

2000

slasher, murder, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Sinister

2012

murder · Horror, Mystery · Blumhouse Productions

The Grudge

2019

Close on feel, same era · Horror, Mystery

Halloween

2018

slasher, murder, serial killer · Horror · Blumhouse Productions

Sinister 2

2015

murder · Horror · Blumhouse Productions

Black Christmas

2006

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Lights Out

2016

Close on feel, same era · Horror, Mystery

Mercy Black

2019

Horror, Mystery · Blumhouse Productions