Movies like My Soul to Take

Cherry Falls

2000

slasher, revenge, serial killer · Horror, Mystery · Rogue Pictures

Black Christmas

2006

slasher, revenge, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Intruder

1989

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Torso

1973

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Maniac Cop 2

1990

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

The Card Player

2004

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Maniac Cop

1988

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

The Strangers

2008

slasher, serial killer · Horror · Rogue Pictures

Killing Ground

2017

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Psycho II

1983

mental illness, revenge, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Toolbox Murders

2004

slasher · Horror, Mystery

Happy Birthday to Me

1981

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

A Nightmare on Elm Street

2010

slasher, revenge · Horror, Mystery

They/Them

2022

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Psycho III

1986

slasher, mental illness · Horror, Mystery

Psycho Killer

2026

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

The Prowler

1981

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery

Truth or Dare

2012

revenge · Horror, Mystery

The Strangers: Prey at Night

2018

slasher, serial killer · Horror · Rogue Pictures

I Know Who Killed Me

2007

serial killer · Horror, Mystery

The Children

2008

slasher · Horror, Mystery

The Unborn

2009

Horror, Mystery · Relativity Media

The Last House on the Left

1972

Also Wes Craven · slasher, revenge · Horror

Black Christmas

2019

slasher, serial killer · Horror, Mystery